Journalist Margot returns to her hometown of Wakarusa, Indiana, to care for her ailing uncle. Her return coincides with the disappearance of a young girl, Natalie. The situation dredges up memories of another unsolved case from twenty years earlier: the abduction and murder of Margot's six-year-old neighbor, January Jacobs. Margot, who was the same age as January at the time, begins to see similarities between the two crimes. As she digs deeper, she encounters resistance from the police, Natalie's family, and the townspeople, all of whom seem to be hiding something. Margot is determined to uncover the truth about Natalie's disappearance and whether January's killer is still at large. This debut thriller by Ashley Flowers is a chilling tale of secrets in a small town.